Land reform underspending left R2.6bn ($150mn) of a South African department’s R10.5bn budget unused last year, most of it meant for restitution claimants, a parliamentary committee found in a report adopted on 18 November.
The Portfolio Committee on Land Reform and Rural Development called the shortfall “a delay in constitutional redress, not merely a financial management matter”, in a country where land ownership remains deeply unequal three decades after apartheid.
How large is the land reform underspending?
Of a final appropriation of R10.468bn, the Department of Land Reform and Rural Development spent R7.865bn, or 75.1 per cent, leaving R2.603bn unspent, according to a statement from the Parliament of South Africa. The land reform and restitution programme accounted for R2.333bn of that, including more than R2.28bn in transfers and subsidies mainly for restitution beneficiaries.
The Commission on Restitution of Land Rights spent R1.935bn of about R4.189bn, or 46.2 per cent, leaving R2.254bn unspent “while claims backlogs persist”, the committee said. The land reform underspending findings are preliminary because the department’s annual report and the commission’s report have not yet been audited and tabled.
What targets did the department miss?
Alongside the land reform underspending, the department met 15 of its 23 annual targets, or 65 per cent, the lowest in five years, the committee said. It allocated 35,539 hectares against a target of 44,000, settled 239 land claims against 281, and created 227 rural development jobs against a target of 450.
Land administration performed best at 89 per cent, while the land reform and rural development programmes each reached 60 per cent and administration 25 per cent. MPs also raised concerns about senior vacancies, a delayed organisational redesign and late financial statements.
What about the Ingonyama Trust and other entities?
The Ingonyama Trust Board, which administers communal land in KwaZulu-Natal, paid R61.3mn to beneficiaries and collected leases well, but again received a qualified audit opinion, and 96 per cent of its debtors are more than 120 days overdue, the committee said.
The Agricultural Land Holdings Account, which holds state land for redistribution, has assets of R16.9bn but about R894.6mn in lease receivables and irregular expenditure above R1bn. The Office of the Valuer-General achieved a clean audit, and the Deeds Registration Trading Entity made a R285.5mn surplus on revenue of R1.285bn, though its electronic deeds system is behind schedule.
What did MPs recommend on land reform underspending?
On land reform underspending, the committee concluded that “the main challenge is no longer funding alone” but the capacity of institutions to turn money into land reform results. It asked the finance minister to review the funding of land reform bodies so that budgets match delivery capacity, and, with the land reform minister, to consider extra money for restitution, support for communal property associations and tenure reform, including obligations from the Mwelase and LAMOSA court cases.
It also called for a conditional grant for post-settlement support, a review of the Agricultural Land Holdings Account’s financial model, and for equitable land access and communal tenure laws to be finalised “without further delay”. Ministers are expected to respond within two months of the National Assembly adopting the report.
Land reform is politically sensitive in South Africa: the Expropriation Act signed in January 2025 drew criticism from the US government and a court challenge by the Democratic Alliance, a partner in the governing coalition. The coalition’s partners have also been tested by local election coalition talks.
FAQ
How much did the land reform department underspend?
R2.603bn of a R10.468bn budget, mostly money meant for restitution beneficiaries, according to the committee.
How many land claims were settled?
239 against a target of 281.
Why does the land reform underspending matter?
The committee said unspent restitution money delays redress for people dispossessed of land, while claims backlogs persist.

