South Africa’s dispute over a Starlink licence flared again after President Cyril Ramaphosa said in California on Monday that Elon Musk should “give back” to his country of birth, and Musk replied that South Africa was “super racist”.
The exchange leaves SpaceX’s satellite internet service locked out of Africa’s most industrialised economy, while a stalled offer to connect 5,000 rural schools for free and a rival deal by Amazon show what is at stake for the country’s connectivity.
What did Ramaphosa say about Musk and Starlink?
Ramaphosa was speaking to Jonathan Karl of ABC News at Semafor’s “Silicon Valley & The World” event, part of a visit by a delegation of nearly 300 people to study the US artificial intelligence industry, according to the government’s announcement of the trip.
“I have met Elon Musk in the past, and I’ve been awed by his brilliance. But I’d also like to chat to him about remembering his country,” Ramaphosa said, in remarks posted by Semafor. He said Musk owed much of his success to his education in South Africa, and that the apartheid state had spent about 12 rand on the schooling of white children such as Musk for every rand it spent on black children.

Asked about Musk’s description of South African policy as “apartheid 2.0”, Ramaphosa said Musk did not fully understand what apartheid had done to black South Africans. On the Starlink licence, he said Musk’s difficulty with the ownership rules was what kept the service out. “All countries have policies in terms of how they admit companies to operate,” he said, adding that companies “have got to subscribe to the policies of the country”. A planned meeting with Musk during the trip did not happen because their diaries did not match, he said.
How did Musk respond?
Musk replied on X on Tuesday that South Africa was “super racist against Whites and Asians”, according to several South African outlets including IOL. He has said before that Starlink cannot get a licence “simply because I am not black”, a claim the government rejects. The government has said the rules for a Starlink licence are the same as for any other operator.

Why is there no Starlink licence in South Africa?
Licensing rules set by the regulator, the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa), require operators to be 30% owned by historically disadvantaged groups. To win a Starlink licence, SpaceX would have to cede that equity in its local business, which it refuses to do. It has pushed for an “equity-equivalent” option, under which multinationals invest in local skills, suppliers or infrastructure instead.
The communications minister, Solly Malatsi, directed Icasa to consider such programmes, but the regulator said in May that it could not fully apply the direction without parliament amending the Electronic Communications Act. The business lobby Sakeliga asked the Pretoria High Court on 9 November to set aside an Icasa decision on the matter, The Guardian reported.
In June 2025, Starlink offered to supply satellite kits and free internet to more than 5,000 rural schools, reaching about 2.4mn pupils, in a package valued at about R500mn ($27mn), if it was allowed to use the equity-equivalent route, according to a letter to the trade minister reported by BusinessDay. The schools remain unconnected through that offer.
What happens next?
A Starlink licence still depends on the law changing, or on a court ruling. In the meantime, Amazon’s rival network has found another way in: Telkom said on Tuesday that it would distribute Amazon Leo satellite broadband to businesses, following a similar deal with Herotel in July. Because local licensed firms remain the service providers, Amazon does not need a licence of its own.
Ramaphosa’s delegation is meeting AI companies and investors in California this week. On Monday DNE Africa reported that the president gave the visiting companies 90 days to deliver projects. The Starlink licence dispute has run for years; in 2025 the government dismissed Musk’s claim that Starlink was blocked over race.
FAQ
Why does Starlink not have a licence in South Africa?
Icasa’s rules require licensees to be 30% owned by historically disadvantaged groups. SpaceX has refused to cede equity and wants an equity-equivalent investment option instead, which Icasa says needs a change in the law.
What did Ramaphosa say about Elon Musk?
He said Musk should give back to South Africa, where he was educated, and that Starlink must follow the country’s rules like any other company.
How did Musk respond?
Musk wrote on X that South Africa was “super racist against Whites and Asians”.
What was the Starlink offer to South African schools?
In 2025 Starlink offered free connectivity to more than 5,000 rural schools, worth about R500mn, if it could use the equity-equivalent route to a Starlink licence.
What would it take to grant a Starlink licence?
Either SpaceX accepts the 30% ownership rule, or parliament amends the Electronic Communications Act so that Icasa can accept equity-equivalent investment instead. A court challenge by Sakeliga is also pending.

